The Trial of Lizzie Borden by Cara Robertson
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Did anyone with the name Lizzie grow up and not have the "Lizzie Borden" rhyme chanted at them?
It's made me endlessly fascinated by the Borden murders. (For the record: I adore the Christina Ricci movie & TV series with Ricci as Lizzie.)
In the late 19th century, Andrew and Abigail Borden were found murdered in their home. Both had been killed by multiple blows from an ax; the scientific evidence said that Mrs. Borden was dead for about two hours before Mr. Borden. Only Lizzie, in her early thirties, and a twenty something maid were at home when the murders took place. Lizzie was arrested, tried, and found not guilty.
And I'll say from the start: No, I'm not convinced she did it.
It's amazing both how much we know and how little we know. And how much the science of the 19th century is relied on.
As per the title, this book relies heavily on the trial transcripts. It's a fascinating, deep look at the trial and how both sides played on the views people held back then, of what women were supposed to be like or what they were supposed to do or not do. Did Lizzie react the right way to the murder of her father and stepmother? Was her alibi suspect because it was a bad alibi, or because folks couldn't believe how a spinster spent her days?
Recommended; and yes, one day I'd like to go to the house were the murders took place.
View all my reviews