Thursday, January 14, 2010

The Museum of Mary Child

The Museum of Mary Child by Cassandra Golds. Kane/Miller. 2009. Review copy from publisher. Ages: middle grade and up.

The Plot: Once upon a time. There was a girl. There was a doll. There was a city. There was a prisoner. There was a museum. There was a madhouse. And there were birds.

Heloise is raised by her godmother and a housekeeper. Her memories of how she arrived at the Cottage are sketchy. The rules of her godmother are odd. Both love and imagination are forbidden. All Heloise wants is what she cannot have -- a doll. When she finds one hidden in the floorboards of her room, the doll whispers "you may call me Maria."

The dark secrets that haunt and govern the lives of Heloise and her godmother are about to be revealed.Bold

The Good: This was one crazy book; both terrifying and reassuring, full of hate and love and the impossible.

The reader has to believe -- believe in the Secret Society of Caged Birds who assist and comfort prisoners. Believe in a Museum full of dolls....all the same doll, over and over, half hidden in walls and floors and chairs and gardens, all with their faces hidden behind a mask of stitches. Believe that a girl can run away and birds can guide her to a safe haven where for once she finds love, acceptance, music and colorful clothes. Believe in magic.

What happens in The Museum of Mary Child is unexpected and full of twists, of nightmares and dreams come to life. It is horror and miracle. It's not the twists of a "gotcha" mystery; rather, it is a stunningly original story that dares to ask what is a miracle? What is faith? What is love? What is life?

Who is the reader for this book? It's fairy tale-ish, yet also scary. On one level, it will work for younger readers looking for a spooky tale. Dolls that talk? Birds that guide people to safety? A museum that haunts ones dreams? This delivers on the horror front.

The Museum of Mary Child also has a distinct literary style, with metaphors and allegories that will appeal to those readers who want something more from a book; who want the caviar, not just the chocolate. It's Margo Lanagan for tweens. Actually, because of the uneasy questions asked and not answered, teens will appreciate this book, also. It may be a harder sell -- Heloise, the main character, is a child for most of the book -- but if they trust you to read the first twenty or so pages, they'll be hooked.

Edited to add to my Favorite Books Read in 2010 (see sidebar). Because I cannot get the questions it raises out of my head. And, well, the dolls.

Amazon Affiliate. If you click from here to Amazon and buy something, I receive a percentage of the purchase price.

© Elizabeth Burns of A Chair, A Fireplace & A Tea Cozy


Charlotte said...

I loved this book; I'm glad to see you did too!

Anonymous said...

Glad to hear your take on this one - I deliberated for a while before I ordered it. Seems like it will have a small but devoted following. And the description of Margo Lanagan for tweens means I need to read it!

Kate Forsyth said...

I really love this book & Cassandra's writing. She has a magical other-worldiness that seems to speak across boundaries.

Therin of Andor said...

Great review!

Cassandra came to my school and read a chapter of this book, hot off the press, to our Year 6 students - and they were *entranced*!

Tasha said...

I really enjoyed this one too!

Sandra Stiles said...

This looks like the perfect book for em to read. You have me intrigued with your review. This goes to the top of my TBR pile. thanks.

Ms. Yingling said...

I'm still waiting for this one to come from the public library. It does look intriguing.

Liz B said...

I'm wondering why this didn't get some more love. And I think it's partly because Kane/Miller doesn't usually do chapter books like this. But I also think its literary, and when literary books for middle grade are discussed, its usually as preAward buzz and this isn't eligible for the Newbery.